Home Articles Giants and Small Antennas

Dr Marcus Walden, Principal consultant Antennas Propagation
Written by Dr Marcus Walden

Principal Consultant - Antennas & Propagation

Giants and Small Antennas

The first documented numerical modelling of the historical Grimeton very low frequency (VLF) antenna was presented by Plextek in the session on Electrically Small Antennas at the IEEE International Symposium on Antennas and Propagation.

This is a very personal journey by Dr Marcus Walden, who has a great appreciation for the genius of Ernst F. W. Alexanderson following a cycling trip to Sweden twenty years ago and has this year resulted in Marcus modelling the ‘Alexanderson antenna’ using the new NEC-5 electromagnetic simulation software.

Sir Isaac Newton once said,

“If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of Giants”.

That statement is equally valid for the greats of science and technology, as it is for the humble practicing engineer.

One of the lesser-known giants of radio engineering was Ernst F. W. Alexanderson, a Swedish engineer who emigrated to the USA at the turn of the last century. He was a prolific inventor, with some 345 patents to his name – the last one awarded when he was 95 years old! One of his many inventions was to become known as the ‘Alexanderson alternator’.

Imagine a large electric motor capable of generating radio frequency (RF), typically at very low frequencies (VLF, which covers 3–30 kHz) and at power levels of tens to hundreds of kilowatts. In the history of radio engineering, the Alexanderson alternator made the spark-gap transmitter obsolete, no bad thing because the latter was an electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) nightmare. It was manufactured by General Electric (GE) and sold by the Radio Corporation of America (RCA), with its heyday around the 1910s and 1920s until it was eventually made redundant by valve technology.

The only functioning Alexanderson alternator in the world is located at Grimeton, close to the town of Varberg in southern Sweden. It had been part of a global RCA network that could be described as the wireless ‘internet’ of the 1920s, albeit operating at much slower data rates because morse code was used. For example, about 1.8 million words were transmitted from Grimeton during 1936, which equates to about 10 MB of data (or about 27 kB per day)!

Its uniqueness and historical relevance enabled the Grimeton site to be classified as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2004 because

“The Varberg Radio Station at Grimeton in southern Sweden (built 1922–24) is an exceptionally well-preserved monument to early wireless transatlantic communication”

Photograph of Alexanderson alternator at Grimeton
Photograph of Alexanderson alternator at Grimeton
Figure 1. Photograph of Alexanderson alternator at Grimeton (1)

Twenty years ago in 2003, my wife and I were on a cycling holiday in Sweden and serendipity took our route past Grimeton. Being late summer and out of season, Grimeton was technically closed but fortune favoured us. Having cheekily knocked at the entrance to the main building, an engineer appeared and after some introductions, he kindly invited us in for a personal tour. As an RF and antenna engineer, not to mention a radio amateur, it was an unmissable opportunity and a classic example of the proverbial ‘busman’s holiday’. I was thrilled but what about my wife? She enjoyed it too!

The main building is only visible once you get close to it, but you can see the ‘Alexanderson antenna’ – another of his inventions – from miles around. Six masts, each 127 m tall, extend in a line nearly 2 km long and support the antenna system. While physically tall, the antenna system is electrically small. The Grimeton alternator transmits at 17.2 kHz, where the wavelength is about 17.4 km, so the antenna electrical height is only about 0.073 wavelengths.

Electrically small antennas typically have low gain and/or narrow bandwidths but the genius of Alexanderson led to the creation of the ‘multiple-tuned antenna’, which provides greater efficiency and wider bandwidth than could ordinarily be achieved. Impressive considering that numerical modelling of antennas on computers was not available to him.

Photograph showing masts 2–6 of the Grimeton antenna system
Photograph showing masts 2–6 of the Grimeton antenna system
Figure 2. Photograph showing masts 2–6 of the Grimeton antenna system (2)

Fast forward to now, just one year before the centenary of Grimeton radio station having been commissioned. Curiosity – blame the radio amateur and technical nerd within me – led me to model the ‘Alexanderson antenna’ at Grimeton.

I use commercial electromagnetic (EM) simulation tools to design and simulate complex antenna systems in my day job but for my home interests, I use the recently released NEC-5 software from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL).

My NEC-5 model of the Grimeton antenna system included lots of technical detail, such as buried ground wires, above-ground equalisation networks, masts, insulators, and tuning inductors. From experience, I know that EM simulations and measurements should be in good agreement if all features of the antenna design are accounted for in the modelling. Reassuringly, my NEC-5 simulation results agreed well with historical literature on the Grimeton antenna system.

What appears to be the first documented numerical modelling of the Grimeton VLF antenna was presented in the session on Electrically Small Antennas at the 2023 IEEE International Symposium on Antennas and Propagation and USNC-URSI Radio Science Meeting (AP-S/URSI 2023) in Portland, Oregon, USA.

AP-S/URSI 2023 is:

“a great international forum for the exchange of information on state-of-the-art research on antennas, propagation, electromagnetic engineering, and radio science”.

Coincidently, my first attendance at an AP-S/URSI meeting was in 2003, just a couple of months before my wife and I cycled past Grimeton.

Simulated 3D radiation pattern and RF currents for the Grimeton antenna model
Simulated 3D radiation pattern and RF currents for the Grimeton antenna model

The Alexanderson alternator at Grimeton now gets activated two or three times a year on special occasions; for example, Christmas Eve and Alexanderson Day, the latter to commemorate the achievements of Ernst F. W. Alexanderson. This year, Alexanderson Day is on Sunday 2nd July.

If you can’t make it to Grimeton in person, you can watch a live YouTube broadcast of the activation, kindly hosted by members of the Alexander Association. Further details can be found here.

During the activation, a message is transmitted using morse code, which typically starts and concludes with the radio station callsign; ‘SAQ’ for Grimeton.

If you have access to a short-wave radio with coverage of VLF, you can also listen to the unique sounds of the morse transmission using the Grimeton alternator, recognisable by the slight drift in tone frequency as it transmits. In the past, signals from Grimeton have been heard around the world.

Even if you don’t have a short-wave radio, you can still listen via one of many software-defined radios (SDR) available on the internet. One such SDR is located at the University of Twente in Holland. Just set the SDR to CW mode, centre it on 17.2 kHz and away you go.

http://websdr.org/

Happy listening. Happy Alexanderson Day.

(1) Gunther Tschuch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Alexanderson_Alternator.jpg
(2) Chrumps By Chrumps – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=42756712
Contact Plextek

Contact Us

Got a question?

If you have got a question, or even just an idea, get in touch


Technology Platforms

Plextek's 'white-label' technology platforms allow you to accelerate product development, streamline efficiencies, and access our extensive R&D expertise to suit your project needs.

  • 01 Configurable mmWave Radar Module

    Plextek’s PLX-T60 platform enables rapid development and deployment of custom mmWave radar solutions at scale and pace

    Configurable mmWave Radar Module
  • 02 Configurable IoT Framework

    Plextek’s IoT framework enables rapid development and deployment of custom IoT solutions, particularly those requiring extended operation on battery power

    Configurable IoT Framework
  • 03 Ubiquitous Radar

    Plextek's Ubiquitous Radar will detect returns from many directions simultaneously and accurately, differentiating between drones and birds, and even determining the size and type of drone

    Ubiquitous Radar
Urban Challenges Rapid RF Propagation Modelling
Urban Challenges: Rapid RF Propagation Modelling

Discover the challenges and solutions for accurately modelling RF propagation in urban settings. Explore the innovative neural network model revolutionising urban RF systems.

Plextek's white paper Sensing in Space
mmWave Technology for Space Sensing and Operations

Discover our advanced mmWave radar platform for safer and more efficient space missions.

Enhancing communication and safety in mining: the role of custom RF system design

We explore the role of custom RF system design in communication and safety within the mining industry, ensuring robust data handling and operational efficiency in challenging conditions.

High-Performance mm-Wave Radar System for in-orbit micro-debris detection - capable of detecting fast-moving particles with relative velocities of up to 15.2 km/s at distances over 60 metres away
Continuing to Lead in Radar Development for Pioneering CLEAR Mission

We continue to advance radar technology for the CLEAR mission, reinforcing the partnership with ClearSpace and the UK Space Agency for sustainable space safety and debris removal.

Revolutionising chronic pain management
Revolutionising chronic pain management

Fusing mmWave technology and healthcare innovation to devise a ground-breaking, non-invasive pain management solution, demonstrating our commitment to advancing healthtech.

An artistic impression of the CLEAR mission. © ClearSpace
Pioneering Advanced In-Orbit Servicing

Pioneering a ground-breaking collaboration in advanced in-orbit servicing, setting new benchmarks for space debris removal and satellite maintenance.

A visual representation of: SSL The Revolution Will Not Be Supervised
SSL: The Revolution Will Not Be Supervised

Exploring the cutting-edge possibilities of Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) in machine learning architectures, revealing new potential for automatic feature learning without labelled datasets in niche and under-represented domains.

Unlocking the mysteries of imaging radar data processing

Looking deeper into the cutting edge of imaging radar data processing, where innovative techniques and practical applications combine to drive forward solutions.

A visual representation of: Advancing space technology solutions through innovation
Advancing space technology solutions through innovation

At the forefront of space technology innovation, we address complex engineering challenges in the sector, delivering low size, weight, and power solutions tailored for the harsh environment of space.

A visual representation of: A Programmer's Introduction to Processing Imaging Radar Data
A Programmer’s Introduction to Processing Imaging Radar Data

A practical guide for programmers on processing imaging radar data, featuring example Python code and a detailed exploration of a millimetre-wave radar's data processing pipeline.

Folded Antennas; An Important Point of Clarification

Exploring the essential nuances of folded antennas, ensuring precision and clarity in this critical aspect of RF engineering and design.

A visual representation of: Are there really any benefits to 5G
Are there really any benefits to 5G?

Questioning the real-world benefits of 5G technology, offering a candid examination of its impact on connectivity and the disparity between expectations and user experiences.


Related Technical Papers

View All
Sensing in space The untapped potential of radar for space-based sensing. And how to get it right.
Sensing in space

Space holds vast promise. Orbiting satellites have already enabled global communications and allowed us to learn about our planet's climate. This paper will explain radar, how it works, and why it is suited to space applications. It will also discuss considerations for space companies when deploying any sensing technology. There is no one-size-fits-all when it comes to sensing. Our team works with space missions to assess if mmWave radar is right, and where it is, identify optimal configurations, software, and security to deliver against the performance and SWaP-C goals.

an image of our technical paper
mmWave Imaging Radar

Camera systems are in widespread use as sensors that provide information about the surrounding environment. But this can struggle with image interpretation in complex scenarios. In contrast, mmWave radar technology offers a more straightforward view of the geometry and motion of objects, making it valuable for applications like autonomous vehicles, where radar aids in mapping surroundings and detecting obstacles. Radar’s ability to provide direct 3D location data and motion detection through Doppler effects is advantageous, though traditionally expensive and bulky. Advances in SiGe device integration are producing more compact and cost-effective radar solutions. Plextek aims to develop mm-wave radar prototypes that balance cost, size, weight, power, and real-time data processing for diverse applications, including autonomous vehicles, human-computer interfaces, transport systems, and building security.

an image of our technical paper
Low Cost Millimeter Wave Radio frequency Sensors

This paper presents a range of novel low-cost millimeter-wave radio-frequency sensors that have been developed using the latest advances in commercially available electronic chip-sets. The recent emergence of low-cost, single chip silicon germanium transceiver modules combined with license exempt usage bands is creating a new area in which sensors can be developed. Three example systems using this technology are discussed, including: gas spectroscopy at stand off distances, non-invasive dielectric material characterization and high performance micro radar.

an image of our technical paper
Ku-Band Metamaterial Flat-Panel Antenna for Satcom

This technical paper by Dr. Rabbani and his team presents research on metamaterial-based, high-gain, flat-panel antennas for Ku-band satellite communications. The study focuses on leveraging the unique electromagnetic properties of metamaterials to enhance the performance of flat-panel antenna designs, aiming for compact structures with high gain and efficiency. The research outlines the design methodology involving multi-layer metasurfaces and leaky-wave antennas to achieve a compact antenna system with a realised gain greater than +20 dBi and an operational bandwidth of 200 MHz. Simulations results confirm the antenna's high efficiency and performance within the specified Ku-band frequency range. Significant findings include the antenna's potential for application in low-cost satellite communication systems and its capabilities for THz spectrum operations through design modifications. The paper provides a detailed technical roadmap of the design process, supported by diagrams, simulation results, and references to prior work in the field. This paper contributes to the advancement of antenna technology and metamaterial applications in satellite communications, offering valuable insights for researchers and professionals in telecommunications.

an image of our technical paper
The Kootwijk VLF Antenna: A Numerical Model

A comprehensive analysis of the historical Kootwijk VLF (Very Low Frequency, which covers 3-30 kHz) antenna, including the development of a numerical model to gain insight into its operation. The Kootwijk VLF antenna played a significant role in long-range communication during the early 20th century. The paper addresses the challenge of accurately modelling this electrically small antenna due to limited historical technical information and its complex design. The main goal is to understand if the antenna’s radiation efficiency might explain why “results were disappointing” for the Kootwijk to Malabar (Indonesia) communications link. Through simulations and comparisons with historical records, the numerical model reveals that the Kootwijk VLF antenna had a low radiation efficiency – about 8.9% – for such a long-distance link. This work discusses additional loss mechanisms in the antenna system that might not have been considered previously, including increased transmission-line losses as a result of impedance mismatch, wires having a lower effective conductivity than copper and inductor quality factors being lower than expected. The study provides insights into key antenna parameters, such as the radiation pattern, the antenna’s quality factor, half-power bandwidth and effective height, as well as the radiated power level and the power lost through dissipation. This research presents the first documented numerical analysis of the Kootwijk VLF antenna and contributes to a better understanding of its historical performance. While the focus has been at VLF, this work can aid future modelling efforts for electrically small antennas at other frequency bands.

an image of our technical paper
The Radiation Resistance of Folded Antennas

This technical paper highlights the ambiguity in the antenna technical literature regarding the radiation resistance of folded antennas, such as the half-wave folded dipole (or quarter-wave folded monopole), electrically small self-resonant folded antennas and multiple-tuned antennas. The feed-point impedance of a folded antenna is increased over that of a single-element antenna but does this increase equate to an increase in the antenna’s radiation resistance or does the radiation resistance remain effectively the same and the increase in feed-point impedance is due to transformer action? Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulations, this study shows that the radiation resistance of a folded antenna is effectively the same as its single-element counterpart. This technical paper serves as an important point of clarification in the field of folded antennas. It also showcases Plextek's expertise in antenna theory and technologies. Practitioners in the antenna design field will find valuable information in this paper, contributing to a deeper understanding of folded antennas.

an image of our technical paper
Chilton Ionosonde Data & HF NVIS Predictions during Solar Cycle 23

This paper presents a comparison of Chilton ionosonde critical frequency measurements against vertical-incidence HF propagation predictions using ASAPS (Advanced Stand Alone Prediction System) and VOACAP (Voice of America Coverage Analysis Program). This analysis covers the time period from 1996 to 2010 (thereby covering solar cycle 23) and was carried out in the context of UK-centric near-vertical incidence skywave (NVIS) frequency predictions. Measured and predicted monthly median frequencies are compared, as are the upper and lower decile frequencies (10% and 90% respectively). The ASAPS basic MUF predictions generally agree with fxI (in lieu of fxF2) measurements, whereas those for VOACAP appear to be conservative for the Chilton ionosonde, particularly around solar maximum. Below ~4 MHz during winter nights around solar minimum, both ASAPS and VOACAP MUF predictions tend towards foF2, which is contrary to their underlying theory and requires further investigation. While VOACAP has greater errors at solar maximum, those for ASAPS increase at low or negative T-index values. Finally, VOACAP errors might be large when T-SSN exceeds ~15.

an image of our technical paper
Antenna GT Degradation with Inefficient Receive Antenna at HF

This paper presents the antenna G/T degradation incurred when communications systems use very inefficient receive antennas. This work is relevant when considering propagation predictions at HF (2-30 MHz), where it is commonly assumed that antennas are efficient/lossless and external noise dominates over internally generated noise at the receiver. Knowledge of the antenna G/T degradation enables correction of potentially optimistic HF predictions. Simple rules of-thumb are provided to identify scenarios when receive signal-to-noise ratios might be degraded.

an image of our technical paper
60 GHz F-Scan SIW Meanderline Antenna for Radar Applications

This paper describes the design and characterization of a frequency-scanning meanderline antenna for operation at 60 GHz. The design incorporates SIW techniques and slot radiating elements. The amplitude profile across the antenna aperture has been weighted to reduce sidelobe levels, which makes the design attractive for radar applications. Measured performance agrees with simulations, and the achieved beam profile and sidelobe levels are better than previously documented frequency-scanning designs at V and W bands.

an image of our technical paper
Midlatitude 5 MHz HF NVIS Links: Predictions vs. Measurements

Signal power measurements for a UK-based network of three beacon transmitters and five receiving stations operating on 5.290 MHz were taken over a 23 month period between May 2009 and March 2011, when solar flux levels were low. The median signal levels have been compared with monthly median signal level predictions generated using VOACAP (Voice of America Coverage Analysis Program) and ASAPS (Advanced Stand Alone Prediction System) HF prediction software with the emphasis on the near-vertical incidence sky wave (NVIS) links. Low RMS differences between measurements and predictions for September, October, November, and also March were observed. However, during the spring and summer months (April to August), greater RMS differences were observed that were not well predicted by VOACAP and ASAPS and are attributed to sporadic E and, possibly, deviative absorption influences. Similarly,the measurements showed greater attenuation than was predicted for December, January, and February, consistent with the anomalously high absorption associated with the “winter anomaly.” The summer RMS differences were generally lower for VOACAP than for ASAPS. Conversely, those for ASAPS were lower during the winter for the NVIS links considered in this analysis at the recent low point of the solar cycle. It remains to be seen whether or not these trends in predicted and measured signal levels on 5.290 MHz continue to be observed through the complete solar cycle.

an image of our technical paper
Electrically small monopoles: Classical vs. Self-Resonant

This paper shows that the Q-factor and VSWR of a monopole are significantly lowered when made resonant by reactive loading (as is used in practice). Comparison with a self-resonant Koch fractal monopole of equal height gives similar values of VSWR and Q-factor. Thus, the various electrically small monopoles (self-resonant and reactively loaded) offer comparable performance when ideal and lossless. However, in selecting the optimum design, conductor losses and mechanical construction at the frequency of interest must be considered. In essence, a trade-off is necessary to obtain an efficient, electrically small antenna suitable for the application in hand.

an image of our technical paper
Ku-Band Low-Sidelobe Waveguide Array

The design of a 16-element waveguide array employing radiating T-junctions that operates in the Ku band is described. Amplitude weighting results in low elevation sidelobe levels, while impedance matching provides a satisfactory VSWR, that are both achieved over a wide bandwidth (15.7-17.2 GHz). Simulation and measurement results, that agree very well, are presented. The design forms part of a 16 x 40 element waveguide array that achieves high gain and narrow beamwidths for use in an electronic-scanning radar system.